Franklin D. Roosevelt described the concept of a “forgotten man” as “at the bottom of the economic pyramid.” The lower class. The derelict. Basically, the “forgotten man” is whom society has left in the dust because they are unable to take care of themselves. During the Great Depression, this applied to a lot of people throughout the country. Roosevelt claimed his “New Deal” would fix some of these problems, but that would take time to implement, which meant a lot of forgotten men and women would remain forgotten for quite some time. My Man Godfrey, released in 1936 and based on a book released in 1935, is a screwball comedy about one such forgotten man.
Godfrey, along with several other homeless men, live in a dump on the edge of New York City during the Great Depression. The NYC upper crust are playing a city-wide scavenger hunt and so that night, a socialite named Cornelia Bullock approaches Godfrey, offering him $5 to be her forgotten man for the scavenger hunt. Godfrey is insulted by the offer (and likely the game as well) and refuses. Cornelia’s sister, Irene, is there as well, and Godfrey finds her to be much kinder and honest, and so he offers to be her forgotten man, if it means she’ll beat Cornelia. At the Ritz, Godfrey is presented and verified as a forgotten man, giving Irene the victory, but Godfrey takes a moment to berate everyone playing the game. Irene apologizes for the game and decides to make Godfrey her protégé – hiring him on as the family butler. In his first day on the job, he is informed by the maid that butlers don’t last long at the Bullock house. Godfrey, however, goes above and beyond the call of duty, proving his staying power, but also inadvertently causing Irene to fall in love with him. He tries unsuccessfully to outline the boundaries of their employee-employer relationship.
Later, Godfrey runs into an old friend of his, Tommy, and so he makes up a story of their relationship, saying he used to be Tommy’s valet. Tommy plays along, adding a wife and children to the story. Irene, after hearing this, impulsively announces her engagement to a young man named Charlie, who is just as shocked as everyone else, but she breaks down into tears when Godfrey congratulates her. Godfrey and Tommy meet for lunch on his day off, and we learn that Godfrey has loved and lost and found the enduring spirit of the forgotten men a comfort to him. Cornelia plants a pearl necklace under Godfrey’s mattress and calls the cops, claiming it’s been stolen, but when the police investigate, the necklace is not there. Irene breaks off her engagement and goes on a trip to get over it, but when she returns, her love for Godfrey is unwavering. She faints and swoons into Godfrey’s arms and so he carries her up to bed, but when he realizes she’s faking it, he throws her in a cold shower. This, according to Irene, only proves that he loves her as well. Godfrey quits at the same time that Mr. Bullock tells his family that he is financially ruined, but Godfrey has one last trick up his sleeve. He pawned the pearl necklace, and used the money to buy Bullock’s stock that he sold short back, and used the remainder to go into business with Tommy opening a nightclub called “The Dump” and hiring the homeless people. Irene argues that since he doesn’t work for her anymore that they can get married, and Godfrey finally has no reason to say “no”.
The film somewhat struggles to balance the romance and the commentary on the effects of the Great Depression to the point where the ending feels very rushed and the resolution to the romance feels shoehorned in. Despite that, however, My Man Godfrey is very funny, charming and uses its two leads to great effect. William Powell and Carole Lombard were married for a time, a few years before the film, and their chemistry really does a lot for the movie. It’s also surprisingly mild for a screwball comedy, compared to some others. In Bringing Up Baby, Katherine Hepburn has a pet leopard that she treats like a child. In His Girl Friday, the lengths Cary Grant and Rosalind Russell go to keep hidden their juicy front-page story is borderline cartoonish. Arsenic and Old Lace has Cary Grant balancing new married life while hiding the fact that his aunts kill men and keep them hidden in a chest. But that’s okay. Where My Man Godfrey lacks in zaniness, it makes up for with pure fun.
Bonus Review: Ball of Fire

Another screwball comedy classic. Ball of Fire was written by Billy Wilder and his longtime-collaborator, Charles Brackett, and directed by the great Howard Hawks. Wilder was growing tired of studio and director interference with his scripts, and so Hawks offered to let him study directing under him on this film to learn the ropes. Wilder never let someone direct a script of his again.
A group of single professors live together in a house where they are compiling an encyclopedia of all human knowledge. Professor Potts is researching modern American slang for his contribution, but is made aware that he is way behind the times for it. He meets a nightclub performer who calls herself “Sugarpuss”, and asks for her help in his research. Sugarpuss is reluctant at first, but agrees after the cops coming knocking on her door to ask questions about her boyfriend, Joe Lilac, a local mob boss. Sugarpuss comes to stay with Potts and the other professors to avoid the police and helps him in his slang research. Meanwhile, Joe decides to marry Sugarpuss because, as his wife, she will not be allowed to testify against him in court. Sugarpuss teaches the professors slang terms as well as how to conga, and slowly falls in love with Potts. He reciprocates her feelings by proposing to her. She does not give an answer right away, hesitant by the sudden request, and agrees to have the professors drive her to New Jersey to marry Joe. Once there, she realizes how much she loves Potts, but she is forced to marry Joe or his henchmen will dispatch the professors. The professors, however, outsmart Joe and his henchmen, and run off with Sugarpuss and she and Potts profess their feelings for one another.
Gary Cooper and Barbra Stanwyck make a great pair in this film, but my favorite part about this film is the other professors. They were modeled after the seven dwarves from the Disney film, Snow White and the Seven Dwarves, and they are the funniest part of an already hilarious movie. Especially with the slang, the movie feels incredibly dated, but honestly, I think that just makes it funnier.







